Saturday, February 5, 2011

Nihilism vs. Meaning ... or ... Nihilism AND Meaning?

Dreamily and lyrically, Hermann Hesse crafted a tale so plagued with unanswerable questions and challenges that many-a-caring high school English & Literature teacher insisted that the developing adolescent mind be exposed to such. In concert with phenomenological thought, I am certain that each teacher possesses utterly unique reasons for engaging young minds with such a text, whether it be to illustrate to the (perhaps banal portrayal of) the 'all-knowing' teen that the universe possesses innumerable unknowns, or whether it be to illustrate that sometimes 'maturity' simply means following one's sometimes irrational heartfelt longings, even if that means brashly not following that which is popular and willfully outcasting oneself from acceptable society. I don't know, maybe I'm being too optimistic that there are such existentially-aiming or existentially-attuned high school literature professors (or maybe I am not giving enough credit to the moving endeavors of early educators...likely this much of the time). I will discuss at a later time the idea if one can ever be existentially-uninformed and, thus, not be existentially-aimed in their own unique manner. Again, another time...

In any case, the poetic Hesse offers a powerfully grave pondering through his protagonist, the spiritually wandering/seeking/questing Siddhartha:


"He saw merchants doing business, princes leaving for the hunt [...] and none of it was worth the trouble of his glance, it was all a lie, it all stank, it all stank of lies, it all gave the illusion of meaning and happiness and beauty, and it was all acknowledged decay. The world had a bitter taste. Life was torment" (Hesse, 1999, p. 7)

In a paradoxical amalgamation of concurrence and aversion, I encountered an unnerving and existentially-unraveling identification with Siddhartha. I vividly recall a placement in life where ambitions to "things," financial gains, and general comfort life seemed a worthy and reasonable goal, if not the goal of humankind. Viewing the life endeavors surrounding me, such consumeristic approaches to existence abounded. I believe that I, too, succumbed to Heidegger's 'The They' or Kierkegaard's 'The Crowd' ... the fallacy that if "all" seemingly find meaning in life in a similarly conforming manner, you too must 'fall into line,' for obviously this must be the meaning of life. Enter: "The American Dream." Clinically, this is where one may encounter an individual enveloped by the luxuries of materialistic life: 6-figure salary, large suburban mansion, SUV's, exotic vacations, and countless technological toys. Why, then, would such an individual who 'has it all' present for therapy? Because, underlying the societally-lauded 'success' remains an existential void, that all one does is mundane. One feels no desire to continue such a path. Befuddled themselves on how they can 'have it all' and still experience anxiety and discontent, they ask 'why am I not happy like everyone else?' (As a relevant aside - they frequently inquire why they can't be 'happy like everyone else' ... when, in fact, others feel the same ... also pointing to this particular client as 'happy' while they are not).

Ultimately, given this hypothetical individual is actually wrestling with the above, he/she may approach a horrifying and conclusion that, to life there exists no purpose & no meaning. Bestowed upon them as children and teens and maybe college students, the promise that things and status and comforts will satisfy the soul gradually (or abruptly and unexpectedly) deteriorates, rendering one groundless in life. Suddenly, existence reveals itself as a cruel accident (or divine joke...which makes little theological sense to me).

For Siddhartha, it was not really (at least, in my reading of it) that he was experiencing such a falling-out of the meaning of life. Rather, he appeared sickened by those deluding themselves into that concept that 'things' will satisfy the spirit. In that particular moment, he declared the human existence as and endless cycle of purposeless living; there existed no meaning to life. Saddened by such a mundane and absurd world, his answer was to depart, to spiritually flee the nihilistic cycle of life.

And here, in this nihilistic proclamation, I also encountered a dissonance with his 'answer' to a mundane and purposelessness existence. I will openly admit that an element in this diversion may be a fear of his terrifyingly accurate depiction of existence. I do conceding that living creatures (not solely humans, I maintain) are born into - 'thrown into' - a existence lacking an inherent meaning of life, hence the struggle with the belief that life is without purpose. However, resigning oneself to having to endure a meaningless life, and escape it for this reason like Siddhartha, neglects the wondrous freedom to shape one's ownmost meaning in life. The beauty, or perhaps Divine grace, is the allowance, the liberation to cultivate the life-purpose calling from within the heart of one's being. Random or Divine, I experience life as a blessing of which I am unworthy and fail to truly comprehend, not as a place to escape because we aren't externally bestowed with meaning.

In Siddhartha's defense (even though he is a fictional character), he was approaching the world from a Buddhist framework, rather than a philosophically existential modality (aren't we all existential, though?). Nevertheless, the fact remains that he was, his life meaning was a devotion to this quest of discovering another plane of existence, a spiritual transcendence in service. This all seem like existential meaning to me: motivating forces driving him into passionate living.
cultivating his ownmost meaning. Relinquishing comforts and accepting suffering was undeniably meaningful. Further, while looking to escape in manner

Moreover, I was in awe of his abandonment of possessions and comforts, while concurrently questioning if my comforts and possessions were a superficial manner of living? Granted, I no longer desire the multiple houses, countless amenities and toys. Still, I possess things I enjoy. I own a number of expensive musical instruments and recording equipment, and I find my meaning in moving others through song, or writing this pondering on a Mac computer. Nevertheless, in Siddhartha's ability to embrace suffering and minimize his own 'suffering footprint' on the rest of the world...I experience guilt. It is difficult reconcile, perhaps impossible.

But if I am truly being existential, banishing the idea of a 'correct' manner in living and existing, can I say that these people with ambitions in materials and comforts as 'incorrect?' Or is this my own religious coloring to existence? Or is it that I suspect that these individuals, if allowing such deep and unutterable acknowledgments to surface - that at their core being they feel absolutely void and empty - they would find 'things' as lacking any fulfillment of the soul? I must strive to be fair and respect all individuals' unique life purposes, however much they rub against my own. Oh, but it is so difficult sometimes.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

On the completion of Life

What is the problem? The problem is, remains, always-and-already one of time. The problem is, I have so much I wish to do, craving in a fervent spirit to engage the world in endlessly flourishing ways. Of course, I hope to record the album that perhaps touches a soul or two. I would like to eventually write something toward the existential, perhaps a formal book, perhaps a novel, perhaps both. I yearn to spend my days simply walking through the days of Autumn, crunching the dry leaves and watching the excitement of another school year in some small town in which I now reside. I hope to find God, maybe have a heart-to-heart with Him.

In my golden years, withered and wise, will I collapse into an old rocking chair with a sigh, relieved but exhausted to finally have completed life's rich endeavors? I doubt it! Will a time surface when life has been "finished" and the lush valley of "relaxing" can begin? Unlikely. The problem remains, always-and-already, that life is incomplete by nature. The difficulty is living into this, in spite of this. Then again, is this really the "problem" of life? Or, rather, is it that incompleteness which gives life, makes it full? Is being incomplete and finite a cosmic curse, or is it a Divine blessing?

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Fellow travelers,

My apologies for not being more present to the blog. Appalled when viewing the date of my last entry, I feel ashamed for my existential abandonment of this blog. I am here, still existing. I am in the midst of much school turmoil, but shall return, and soon. I promise.

Sunday, July 25, 2010

Slimming the crowd?

For perhaps those small few who may happen upon this blog or even read semi-regularly, I find no way to cleverly mask my own manner-of-being, who and how I am, those elements in which I believe and live toward passionately. I realize I am attempting to keep this blog anonymous, which conflicts a tad with my last statement. Nevertheless, as an ultimately unique life, I see no point in remaining "politically correct," but rather perceive much use in existing as a transparent soul, into which one can see and ask easily.

That being said, I must address an argument imposed upon other living beings (humans and other animals alike). That is, I tire of being informed of the "overpopulation" of some creatures. As some may realize, this frequently arises within the context of the hunting season, which for some creatures and some regions exists incessantly. "We are really doing society a benefit here, there is just too dern many of them," they state. Thanks for the favor guys. Nonetheless, I continually fail to find killing other living, soulful beings for sport a favor for any loving piece of this thing we call life. This is, however, not my argument...

My argument resides in the utilization of the concept of "overpopulation." It simply does not work and breaks down rapidly. Overpopulation implies the existence of a "correct" population. If such is the case, who determines the correct population? Us humans, the reigners-supreme of the world? Unfortunately, such an approach rests upon an unfounded assumption of superiority. From what source did we gain the keys to Gaia's kingdom? Even from a theological perspective, about which I am very interested, such an interpretation is either literalism or is a questionable reading of Biblical text. For instance, many translations utilize the word "steward" in regards to the relationship between animals and humans. Utterly regardless, though, humans have received no formal statement of the proper balance of humans:animals. There is no "objectively correct" ratio. For Christian individuals, look to the compassionate St. Francis of Assisi as a model. He treasured animals as God's children, preaching them, giving thanks for them, caring for them, and instructing that they too give thanks for their existence.Let us lightly put down the theological/biblical element for a moment, though.

Let us pretend we are wandering, random humans. As our suburbs devastatingly move into the surrounding countryside, we realize, "Oh no! The deer, they are eating all of our flowers!" The response? "Clearly, there is an overpopulation problem." I inquire, what does that mean? There are too many? That, again, implies an objectively correct or preferable number of animals, an optimal number at which animals properly exist. Anything beyond this is just being greedy on their part, right? Rubbish. Do deers exist merely for our sport? Do cows exist simply to provide the ingredients for steak? Are puppies bestowed upon us by the universe to entertain us and obey us. Spiritual or not, I challenge such thoughts. (If I don't have you on board with this, read below entries) From a purely scientific lens, if we have been "lucky" (for randomness/chance is all then it could be, scientifically) enough to exist as humans and not the fly you swat, there still remains no universally correct number of animals. If it is all a universal mistake, how could there be any Truth, any "correct" manner of living, in which animals must be regulated? If you find faith in a transmigration-based belief, then again, is not your humanness a blessing? If you were once the annoying fly, would you wish to be casually swatted out of existence?

We, humans, continually pilfer land from them, decrying their trespassing upon our new backyard when they need to search farther for food. "Overpopulation" remains a human-made, a socially-constructed, concept. It is not real, it is an abstraction, behind which absolutely nothing exists. Animals are more populated than we would most benefit, or like them to be? What a dangerous world would unearth if all annoyances were instantly acted upon, yes? To animals, I am sure we are overpopulated, for we steal land, hunt for pleasure, farm, control, imprison animals without remorse. Planet of the Apes regularly seems silly, as dirty humans are kept in zoos. If you view the reality of what we do to other living, feeling, loving creatures, it is actually rather harrowing.

Thursday, July 15, 2010

Relational, Phenomenological Animalism

Sorry for my extended absence... I have some good thoughts to get out in the coming month or so ... here is a quick tidbit

Buber illustrates eloquently the allowance of an other to be, as they are fully, freely, and recognized as a distinct and whole entity. He contrasts this well with “reflexion,” the tendency to merely acknowledge one’s existence as “part of myself.” That is, one’s worth becomes measured and determined solely through an individual’s use to the other person. The being is not worthy simply as a consequence of living; rather, one approaches in a “what use are you to me” manner. In any case, I recognize well the struggle to not consider others in such a way. Generally enfolded into the umbrella of selfishness, it remains easy (or lazy) to consider another’s worth to myself; effortful is the intention of allowing the whole of an other as is.

My relational situations with animals yields an interesting example of the above. My girlfriend and I have a dog, actually it is her dog, Steve. He is a very small, all-black Yorkie. Admittedly, my affection toward him has grown intensely and immeasurably. I love him dearly. Growing up, a dog was ever-present in the household. That is, I always felt I “knew” dogs pretty well. As my own existential journey and accompanying questions grow, however, so do my existential considerations toward animals. That is, I wonder of what they think. Do they wonder of their plight, their mortality, their forced submission to humans? With this increasingly on my mind, I am about walking Steve, an extremely loving and nervous creature, with my girlfriend’s sister in tow, visiting from out of town.

She views Steve’s “poor” and “undisciplined” behavior, such as walking around corners before his master and running quickly to the end of his leash, and begins to offer advice. “He is handling you,” she exclaims. “You have to show him you are the leader of the pack.” At one point in my life, I may have heeded such offerings, continuing to behaviorally modify my animals. As I continue to envision animal’s existential throwness, including attempts at sympathetically imagining myself in similar facticities, I can become saddened, at the leash constricting their movement and at the walls surrounding their existence. In essence, while I treasure their presence and its benefits to me, I increasingly experience a deep remorse regarding my own hand in their captivity. In essence, I am saddened by their lack of freedom. Therefore, when inviting advice from the future sister-in-law, I felt dissent. Compliance from the other (in this case, little Steve) no longer exists as my goal. No longer is the aim to solely possess him for gain. Within his terribly constricted existence, which I do believe he enjoys with me at times, can I offer him additional freedoms? Indeed, sometimes when he pulls at the leash so hard I become annoyed. More frequently, though, if I run with him when he does this, simulating a freedom-from-leash-ed-ness, I smile and laugh at his delightful and joy-filled run. Increasingly, when safe, I let him off the leash and walk with him.

Friday, May 28, 2010

See You Soon

While I hesitate to offer a broad generalization to humanity (or moreso to life in general), saying “goodbye” to another is beyond a mere difficulty or struggle. That is, rarely have I encountered the infrequent event of one individual saying goodbye to another. “Bye” and goodbye’s of a sort exist and happen all the time, no doubt. But one person, offering to another person, a final statement of departure – an acknowledgment that I will never see you again in this life – is so truly rare. Yet, how often does one encounter such a situation, where one wholeheartedly realizes that paths will not cross again? My guess is frequently. Many of these, perhaps, are mere chance crossings in life that personally and internally matter very little. A distant cousin you have met at a family reunion, for example. Still, consider the “goodbye” occurring between the two individuals. “Good talking to you. I’m sure I’ll run into you again.” “So great to meet you, your Uncle has my e.mail, so just get in touch sometime.” Are you sure, though, that you will run into them again? I propose (although wary of blanketing such a statement, while realizing I am anyway) that such statements and manners of leaving or ending-in-the-world are delays or avoidances of truly acknowledging the gravity of the moment. Am I guilty of this? Of course! For instance, when I encounter the occasional “Have a nice life!” comment, I think to myself how odd this person is. Yet, is he/she being more honest than myself?


So, what is it? Why the reluctance? I argue or posit that this tendency results from the natural being-fear of finitude, temporality, mortality. To say goodbye with the heart and meaning of the word in mind is to recognize endings, that our time with others will end, that we will cease to be. I think of those rare instances where I have seen or imagined “real” goodbyes: standing with a beloved pet as they are ‘put down,’ watching his eyes looking into mine and asking many questions, or perhaps worse, having no idea they will never open again. Watching his breathing slow and finally cease. This, to me, is ultimately sad. I get teary-eyed merely thinking about it, every time. Similarly, I recall wondering every time I bid farewell to my Grandpa if that was the last. Then, I begin to wonder if, honestly, I will see them again, in any life. A number of religions offer the promise of reunion, and I find comfort. Yet as faith is not steadfast certainty, I ponder such afterlife meetings. That is, I pose the most terrifying question of all: Am I just duping myself into comfort because I’m so horrified of not seeing these beings again? Because I’m so afraid of saying goodbye, for the final time. I hope not. I pray not.

Sunday, April 4, 2010

Do-Gooder

Yes, defending altruism's legitimate existence remains a difficult argument in which to engage. Undoubtedly, those arguments illuminating the intangible gains of helping another seem nothing-but-true. That is, it is a difficult task to say altruism exists, and we humans are not perpetually selfish.

Perhaps you are thinking, "this is a worn-out argument." Is it, though? This philosophical, psychological, evolutionary-scientific argument would basically "decide" whether or not the human species (and other animal species, for that matter) are ultimately selfish, or are granted the freedom to break loose from hedonism should we so desire.

So, what about Neuroscience's evidence on the matter? Engaging in an action that benefits another while detracting from oneself apparently activates the Mesolimbic system of the brain: the brain's basic reward system. This is the same system implicated in drug-taking behavior. So is this evidence of our selfishness? I don't think so. Engaging in an action merely to benefit yourself from it - and doing a good deed "just because" and benefiting from a sense of wellbeing as pleasant side effect are two different things entirely. Just because one benefits does not mean they acted simply to gain a reward of sorts.

Perhaps a new argument (perhaps not, I don't know) is that from the view of one who believes altruism does not exist. Does this individual (the non-believer) gain from an altruistic act? Maybe if they aren't directly contemplating the fact that they
will gain from such an event, then they do. Then, as a consequence of a thoughtful act, they are bestowed with good will (or endorphins or dopamine). This unearths several questions:
1.) What was the motivation, then? Are we posing altruism as some "unconscious" act, where our body secretly knows (that sneaky body of ours) that we will revel in some warmthy goodness if we do some good deed, so it urges us along to do it without informing our "conscious mind." Wow. That is kind of hardcore for an element that is not physiologically needed for survival. Okay, but if we aim in bettering another through the sacrifice of our own self
without knowledge of its benefits, is that not an ultimately selfless act? If we are not consciously aimed toward a "prize," aren't we by definition engaging in altruism?
So follow me...
2.) If one knowingly aims to aid another
because they expect to feel good as a consequence, do they actually garner a warm emotional-soulful sensation? Does the warmth only follow one's intention to receive nothing in return for the giving of one's self? Instead, does one feel ashamed for having done something "good" only to ultimately better their own being?

I think it boils down to freedom. We may engage in a selfless act. It may be rewarding. Ultimately, though, we don't have to. Sometimes we give. Sometimes that is enough.